Which is Better a Shingle or Metal Roof?

Which is Better a Shingle or Metal Roof?

It may be high time that you considered installing a new roof. You can come across numerous options in the market. Asphalt shingles are reliable, requ

5 Ways To Keep Your Home Pest-free
What to Do if Boiler Stops Working?
5 Practices To Maintain Your Sprinkler System

It may be high time that you considered installing a new roof. You can come across numerous options in the market. Asphalt shingles are reliable, require less maintenance, and affordable, thus being the most preferred roofing material. There are other options available like metal roofing that is known for its variety of styles, longevity, and durability. For residential roofing, both materials are undoubtedly amazing options. But you need to invest in one that suits your specific needs. 

Finish options

Both materials are available in different finish options to suit every housing style. If you want a traditional look, then shingle roofs are the best choice. These days, they are created to mimic tile, wood shakes, and slate. They are also available with scalloped edges to be used in Victoria homes. Also, you can find that terracotta look for your Mediterranean home. There are wide ranges of color palettes and different finishes to choose from. It includes subtly multi-colored to slightly weathered ones. 

Metal roofs traditionally are designed using corrugated tin panels referred to as standing-seam metal. It evokes the images of sheds or barns. You can also find them made of copper and tin as well as galvanized metals, aluminum, and zinc. This roofing type better suits more refined, rustic structures. They are also available in a wide range of finishes, colors, in a shake, slate, and shingle styles. 


Metal roofs are designed to withstand the harsh elements of Nature. Manufacturers offer warranties of about 30-50 years on these products. But improper walking, falling branches, and extreme hail may dent such roofs. 

On the other hand, shingles come with less lifespan due to their unique weakness. Chronic damp conditions and pooling water may cause fungus/algae growth while ice dams may cause cracks. Moreover, spikes in temperature during the day or night may reduce its life. This roofing material is provided with a 15-30 year warranty, which again depends largely on climate, environment, and your region.


Although metal roof offers much more longevity and its installation is quite expensive. They are charged per square foot. Asphalt shingles are more affordable than metal roof per square foot. However, its installation is considered to be a specialized job. 

Since metal roofs are durable and can be used for a long time, there is no need for periodical replacement. Also, insurance companies do provide discounts to metal-roofed homes. You may also enjoy tax credits if it is your primary home. These roofs are also energy efficient allowing you to save on cooling/heating costs. 

So, you need to determine the above factors and do more research to find out which one suits your needs.